1 - 20 of 33 Works in Benjamin Cyrus
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
THIS IS A RE-WRITE!! The original is on my page :))
What if Spencer Reid grew up in Benjamin Cyrus' religious cult, The Separatarian Sect, as his protege? What if Spencer believed he was the prophet he was told he is? What happens when his entire world is upended? Healing is not a 'normal' process and Spencer Reid is not a normal boy.
I don't know if this is more or less graphic than the original (considering i'm old now and not as edgy) so please take care of yourselves!!
-
Tags
Summary
Ben’s gaze lingers on Prentiss like some sort of twisted staring contest, but the gun never fully leaves Reid. His eyes flick between the two agents, weighing the risk of sacrifice against cold suspicion, innocence against guilt. Then, with a sudden jerk of his chin, he gestures towards the stairs, the same one Reid had watched girls disappear down with heads hung low. “He stays,” Ben states, voice lower than usual but certain.
Reid’s stomach drops. “What?” he finds himself asking aloud.
“The innocent must not suffer further with the guilty. God commands me to shield you, and so I must place you where no sin can touch you. You will be safe as long as you remain where I put you.” Ben explains, as simply and casually as if he were discussing the weather. “The innocent must be shielded from corruption. God commands me to protect the pure.”
-------------------
Or, Minimal Loss goes a little differently, and Reid gets caught in the crossfire.
Day 8:
“How scared should I be right now?”
Flashing lights | whumper’s return |panic roomSeries
- Part 8 of Whumpcember 2025
-
i’ll always lose (what i can’t solve) by sonic_theredwoodtree
Fandoms: Criminal Minds (US TV)
01 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
It's been a year since Emily told JJ the entirety of everything that happened when she was Lauren Reynolds, and just when she finally started to live instead of just going through the motions of life everyday she tells Benjamin Cyrus that she's the FBI agent to spare Spencer.
And everything that happens after feels like Doyle is happing all over again.
-
can’t really be read as a stand alone so I recommend reading the first part of this series first
also thank you to SSA_JJ_May for the idea to write this version of Emily during minimal loss
Series
- Part 2 of but power isn’t pain
-
Tags
-
give him one thousand lives (and let me take them all) by spencermorgans (wearfinethingsalltoowell)
Fandoms: Criminal Minds (US TV)
29 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Benjamin Cyrus doesn't die in Colorado. Before the BAU can apprehend him, he vanishes, Spencer in his clutches, and the team tries to move on without him.
-
Tags
Summary
There is TOO MUCH that is not addressed about Emily’s trauma… So basically this is just Emily’s trauma getting revealed to her entire team. (Evolution team)
-
Tags
Summary
What if Spencer was raised by the Separatarian Sect, destined to take over when Benjamin Cyrus dies? What happens when realization dawns, when he gets his freedom, and is dragged back into it all again?
!WARNING! - Pedophilic relationships, physical and mental abuse, SA, gaslighting, ect. is featured in this fic. Please be careful and note that none of this is appropriate or romantic behaviour. Spencer is a victim, Cyrus is an abuser.
-
Tags
Summary
In the midst of a dangerous case, Emily Prentiss and Aaron Hotchner find themselves caught in a tense, life-threatening situation when a bomb threat puts their team in danger. After narrowly escaping the threat, the two are left grappling with the aftermath and their complicated feelings toward one another. While the situation forces them to confront their fears and vulnerabilities, it also brings them closer, leading to an unexpected shift in their dynamic.
Emily, struggling with the trauma of the bombing incident, seeks solace in Aaron's company. Despite the tension between them, Aaron insists on being there for her, offering her comfort as she processes the emotional toll of the ordeal. However, their closeness complicates things further, with both of them unsure of where they stand in relation to one another.
Disclaimer: I do not own any of the characters or parts of the orginal storylines.
-
Tags
Summary
Cyrus disappears with Reid in his hold. Just over two years later, he returns, but he isn't the same.
-
Tags
Summary
They both hugged, but that night I would have liked to be the one to protect her, but it didn't happen like that, everything just happened and we returned home again, with a case solved, minimal losses and some pending revelations in the future.
Emily never found out how bad Hotch had it outside while she was beaten by Cyrus. What if they had told him?
-
i keep on waiting for a sign (i regret you all the time) by oncemorewithwhump
Fandoms: Criminal Minds (US TV)
15 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Spencer offers himself up to Cyrus to ensure Emily makes it out of the compound alive.
-
Tags
Summary
When the standoff between the FBI and the cult stretches from days to weeks to a month, Reid goes into heat. Cyrus, citing religious scripture, refuses to allow him to go through it alone. Seeing no other way to save Reid from the alphas of the cult, Emily volunteers to be his heat partner.
-
Tags
Summary
Spencer and Emily get trapped in Cyrus’s cult’s compound and he knows one of them is an FBI agent. Things go a bit worse than canon.
-
Tags
Summary
Emily takes the fall for Spencer. Set during "Minimal Loss", S4 E3.
I do not give permission for this work to be shared outside of Ao3 and my tumblr @gemwritesforkicks.
Prompt fill for Criminal Minds Kink Bingo 2024.
Series
- Part 11 of Criminal Minds Kink Bingo 2024
-
Tags
Summary
Benjamin donne beaucoup d’attention à Spencer. Il a peut-être une façon de s’assurer qu’il est encore plus attaché à lui…
- Language:
- Français
- Words:
- 1,392
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 8
- Hits:
- 189
-
Tags
Summary
After his release from prison, Spencer Reid’s life spiralled into darkness with no sign of a light at the end of the tunnel. When he wakes up in a psychiatric facility with no memory of how he ended up there, you’re the only person he wants to see. But in order to do that, Spencer’s going to need to piece back together his fractured mind and face some cold hard truths.
-
Tags
Summary
Minimal Loss
Episode 3, season 4, Criminal minds. Ending rewritten because it did not get the ending it deserved.Hotch/Reid
Series
- Part 5 of Whumptober 2023
-
i’m holding my breath with a baseball bat — though i’m not sure what i’m waiting for by ChristmasEve12
Fandoms: Criminal Minds (US TV)
17 Aug 2023
Tags
Summary
He curls in on himself, ceramic still slicing into his skin. Morgan tries to rush towards him, but there’s not enough time.
“Gods will,” Jessica repeats, voice breathless and something faraway in her eyes.
She presses the button, and there’s a click. A scream. A burst of something impossibly loud.
And then nothing.
-
Tags
Summary
What if Episode: s04e03 Minimal Loss ended differently? What if Spencer ended up getting stuck in the bombed church?
-
Tags
Summary
Dr. Jane Hart has been with the BAU since practically the start, before Emily and Elle or even Morgan and Reid. Yet somehow - no one seems to know anything about her. But even the best pretenders can't hold against profilers forever, no matter how hard they try. Secrets and lies have a way of coming out in the end, after all. (Nonlinear. AU. Fem!OC)
CHAPTERS GET LONGER OVER TIME. COMPLETED.