Work Text:
Bruce had decided he wasn’t going on a Monday. He didn’t decide it so much that common sense and courtesy decided for him. He didn’t belong at an event celebrating fathers.
The invitation had come through the official League channels, which meant it had been formatted with the specificity of Diana’s organizational instincts and the optimism of Barry’s event-planning energy:
Justice League Family Appreciation Evening
Father’s Day Celebration
Watchtower Conference Suite B
Dress: Smart Casual
Children Welcome
RSVP by Friday
Jason appeared in the Cave on a Wednesday. Not through the Manor, but through the Cave entrance, which Jason still had codes for, which Bruce had never revoked and never intended to, which was its own form of something neither of them discussed. He came in on his motorcycle and pulled off his helmet and walked over to where Bruce was sitting at the Batcomputer and said, without preamble:
"You're going to the Father's Day thing."
"I'm not," Bruce said.
"Wrong answer."
"Jason—"
"You don't get to skip it." Jason's voice was flat and certain, the voice he used when he'd already had the argument in his head and resolved it. "I know what you're thinking. You're thinking you're a shitty father and you don't deserve to be in a room full of people celebrating fatherhood and showing up would be—what. Presumptuous. Offensive. Pick your word."
Bruce said nothing, which was confirmation.
"Here's the thing," Jason said. He sat on the edge of the console, arms crossed. "You don't get to use your guilt as an excuse to dodge things anymore. That's not humility, B. That's just another way of making it about you." He paused. "You want to deal with the consequences of what you did? Fine. Great. Part of the consequences is sitting in a room and watching other people be better dads than you were and not looking away from it. That's the consequence. You don't get to hide in the Manor and call it penance."
Bruce looked over at him.
Jason's jaw was set. His eyes glinted with anger, but there was something underneath the anger, something else—something that was still there despite everything, that Bruce was trying to deserve in the slow way of someone rebuilding a wall brick by brick.
"Tim's going," Jason said. "Cass said maybe. Steph said she'll decide on the day." He paused. "I'm going. You're going. We'll sit at the back. You'll observe. You will not make it about yourself. And then you'll go home." He looked at Bruce steadily. "Simple."
"Jason—"
"Simple," Jason said again. "Say yes, Bruce."
The Cave was quiet.
Bruce looked at his hands. The scars. The calluses. The hands that had hurt and the hands that were trying to learn something different.
He looked up and his eyes caught on the batarang scar on one side of Jason’s neck.
"Yes," he said.
Jason nodded once, with the expression of someone who had expected to win but had prepared for a longer fight. He stood up.
"Selina's coming too," he said. It was not a question.
"If she wants to."
"She wants to." Jason picked up his helmet. "I called her."
Bruce stared at him. "You called Selina."
"Someone had to organize you." He pulled on his helmet. "Seven o'clock. Don't be late."
He left the way he'd come.
Bruce sat in the Cave with the Batcomputer and the dark and the decision he'd apparently just made, and looked at the Father's Day invitation still open on the screen.
He left it open.
The conference suite had been transformed.
This was Barry's doing, visible in the ambition of it, and Diana's doing, visible in the execution—the gap between concept and reality was where Diana lived, and she had apparently decided that smart casual dinner meant round tables with linens, low lighting strung from the ceiling in warm clusters, a small stage at the front with a proper microphone and a backing track setup, and floral arrangements on every table that Hal had complained about and Diana had ignored.
The Watchtower smelled of flowers and the good catering service Barry had found, which was a profoundly strange combination with the ambient technology of the space, and somehow worked.
Families were beginning to arrive.
Children were in their good clothes, some more successfully contained in them than others. Wally's six-year-old twins, Jai and Irey immediately destabilized a floral arrangement. Roy’s nine-year-old Lian claimed the table nearest the stage with the efficiency of a small person who understood real estate. Hal’s eight-year-old son, Martin ran about, leaving Hal rushing in his wake. J'onn stood near the entrance looking moved in the particular way J'onn looked moved—completely still, eyes very warm, taking in the room with the quality of someone who understood what humans were doing when they made celebrations out of love.
Bruce and his table arrived at seven-oh-two.
Selina looked stunning in a single strap bottle green dress, her dark hair up, Rascal's disapproval visibly left at home. Tim was in an actual suit—navy blue, which he wore with the slight discomfort of someone who owned many suits and had feelings about all of them. Jason was in his version of smart casual, which was a black shirt with all the buttons done and a jacket that fit correctly, which he'd clearly made an effort about and would deny if asked. Cass had come in a plain black dress—she'd appeared at the Manor at six-fifty without announcement and gotten in the car, which was all the confirmation anyone needed. Stephanie was in a white dress with a floral lavender print that was aggressively cheerful in a way that suggested she was still deciding what this evening meant to her and had chosen to be louder than the uncertainty.
They found a table at the back.
Bruce sat with his back to the wall, which was habit, which would probably always be habit. He could see the whole room from here. He'd told himself this was tactical. It was also the position of someone who wanted to be able to see what was coming.
Dinah and Oliver entered the suite soon after. Oliver raised a hand in greeting at Bruce, while Dinah gave him a curt nod and proceeded to avoid eye contact. They approached the table at the front where Roy and Lian were seated with Wally’s family.
“Grandpa!” yelled Lian, launching herself straight into Oliver’s arms. Oliver threw his head back and laughed.
Roy got up to embrace and give Dinah a kiss.
The couple exchanged offspring, and this time Lian seemed to marvel at “Grandma Dinah’s” outfit and hairstyle while Oliver pulled Roy into a hug.
Bruce’s jaw tightened. Despite having failed Roy before, Oliver still got to hug his son.
Jason shot him a knowing look.
The Lane-Kents arrived at seven-fifteen.
Bruce saw them before Jason did, which meant he had approximately four seconds to compose himself before Jason noticed and looked at him and then looked at the door and then looked back at Bruce with the expression of a man recalculating the evening.
Clark appeared first, in a two-piece baby blue suit over a crisp white shirt. He had a car seat in one hand, that held his and Lois’s new baby—a barely two-month-old Lara Martha Lane-Kent. Clark lifted the car seat up and grinned at her. Lara looked back with sleepy blue eyes and a very round face framed by tiny black curls. Lois appeared next, elegant as ever in a floor-length dark red dress with long sleeves and her hair held loose in a sleek do. Then came Jon, taller than the last time Bruce had seen him, fourteen going on something else, already scanning the room with the adaptive awareness of someone who'd grown up understanding that rooms contained more than they showed.
And then Dick.
Bruce had known, abstractly, that Dick might attend. Had prepared for it the way he prepared for difficult things—with the controlled awareness of someone who had done the prior work and accepted the likely reality and was managing it. He'd prepared for the possibility.
He had not, it turned out, adequately prepared for the actuality.
Dick was wearing a sky-blue shirt paired with heather grey slacks and a waistcoat. His hair was longer than the photograph in Lois's article, softer, less composed. He was laughing at something Jon had said—not the performance laugh, not the press-ready one, the real one, the surprised one.
Something fluttered in Bruce’s chest. This was his first time seeing Dick in over a year. And he looked—
He looked like someone who had put down something very heavy and learned, over time, how to walk without the compensation.
He looked like himself.
Bruce pressed his hand flat against the table and held it there.
Selina's hand found his other hand under the table.
He turned his palm over and held on.
Dick didn't see Bruce.
Or if he did, he didn't show it—but Dick had always been better at not showing things than Bruce had given him credit for, so this proved nothing. He settled at a table near the front with the Lane-Kents, between Clark and Jon.
Clark had set the car seat down on the table and watched on as Dick cooed at Lara. Dick reached out and unfastened the straps before carefully supporting the baby’s head and pulling her into his arms. Lara wore a tiny white romper with countless ruffles and a small white bow in her hair. She snuffled and looked peaceful in her eldest brother’s arms.
Dick looked at the stage.
Clark said something to him. Dick smiled—the smaller, realer one—and said something back and Clark's hand came briefly to the back of his neck and then dropped, easy and natural, and Dick leaned slightly into the touch and Bruce—
Bruce looked at the tablecloth.
He looked at the tablecloth for a moment. Then he looked up.
"You okay?" Selina said quietly, near his ear.
"Yes," he said, and meant it and didn't mean it and meant it anyway, because the two things could be true at once. He'd learned that. You can hold the grief and the gladness in the same hand. They're not opposites.
"He looks good," Tim said, from across the table. Carefully. His voice calibrated to exactly the level of observation that didn't require a response.
"He does," Bruce said.
He did.
The evening began.
Barry, as host, was either brilliant or chaotic or both, which seemed to be the consistent state of Barry Allen in formal settings. The format was loose: League members' children, or family members, would come to the stage and do whatever they'd prepared. A joke, a song, a memory, a drawing held up to the microphone. The brief and the elaborate both welcomed.
Wally’s son Jai told a joke that was technically a riddle and explained the answer before anyone could guess and then looked puzzled by the laughter. Hal's son Martin sang something from a musical with the absolute commitment of a eight-year-old who had been to one musical and absorbed it completely. Barry and Wally performed a skit together that had everyone in stitches. J'onn's niece, M’gann gave a speech in Martian that J'onn translated in real time and by the end of which J'onn was not translating anymore because he couldn't speak.
Diana had not warned anyone that she had a brief video prepared. It was a collection of small moments filmed by the younger heroes with their fathers, uncle and male mentors during missions and daily life alike. Almost everyone in the room was in the video. Everyone but Bruce.
Selina’s hand tightened around Bruce’s. Bruce squeezed back.
The League was, collectively, a disaster at maintaining composure. Barry was crying by the third act. Hal was doing the thing men did when they were crying and didn't want to be caught, which was the thing of looking slightly upward and to the right and pressing their lips together. Even Arthur, present via League obligation and generally not the most demonstrative person in any room, had a quality of stillness that indicated internal activity.
Clark was watching the stage with the expression of a father at a recital—warm and present, Lara now dozing in his lap, Jon beside Dick with his arms crossed and his jaw doing the thing it did when Jon was trying to look unaffected and wasn't.
Bruce watched all of this from the back.
Not looking away. That was the promise he'd made—to Jason, to himself, to the ongoing project of accountability that didn't get to take the night off because the room was full of things he'd failed to be.
He watched. He didn't look away.
The performances were seemingly winding toward the end when Barry checked his list, looked up with slight confusion, and said into the microphone: "Okay, we've got one more. Dick Grayson."
The room shifted.
Not loudly. Just the particular reorientation of attention when something unexpected enters the schedule. Bruce felt Jason go still across the table. Tim straightened almost imperceptibly.
Dick was standing up.
He had the quality of someone who had made a decision some time ago and was now simply following it through, which was different from someone who was nervous, though perhaps the difference was technical. He touched Clark's shoulder as he passed—just briefly, his hand resting there for a second—and Clark looked up at him with an expression that asked a question and Dick smiled at him with the answer and moved toward the stage.
"Did you know about this?" Jason said, quietly, to Tim.
"No," Tim said.
They both looked at the stage.
Dick took the microphone. He looked out at the room with the equanimity of someone who had performed in front of crowds since he was four years old and had never entirely lost the comfort of it.
"I'm going to sing something," he said, which was already news to most of the room. "It's in French by a Belgian artist called Stromae. He looked at the microphone for a moment. Then at the room. “This song is dedicated to my two fathers. To my biological father, John Grayson, who taught me what it meant to fly and who I’ve been looking for since I was eight years old.” He stopped and took a breath. “And to Clark Kent, who I found.”
The room was already quiet. Bruce swallowed.
At the front table, Lois put down her phone and picked it up again immediately and pressed record.
Clark's face—Bruce could see it from the back of the room, had always had good eyes, would always be watching this particular face across any distance available—Clark's face had done something that it didn't often do. Something open and undone and absolutely uncontrolled.
His eyes were already bright before Dick had sung a single note.
Lara, in Clark’s arms, blinked sleepily at the stage.
Jon though, was grinning with the particular mischief of having known exactly what was coming.
The opening notes of the piano came through the speakers.
Dick closed his eyes for a moment. Then opened them.
And sang.
Later, the people in that room would struggle to describe it with precision—not because the voice was indefinable but because what happened when he sang was not entirely about the voice. Dick’s voice was extraordinary, this was simply true, a thing none of them had known and all of them would carry: warm and clear and passionate with the particular quality of someone singing something that was completely their own, not performed outward but expressed from somewhere real and specific and interior.
But what made the room go the way it went was the combination. Not just the voice, but the emotion in the voice.
Où t'es, papaoutai?
Où t'es, papaoutai?
Where are you, daddy? A child asking a question of an absent figure. A figure who was present in form but gone in every way that mattered, the specific grief of the person who was there and not there, whose body was in the room and whose attention was somewhere else, who passed on silence instead of presence, who could not show what they were never shown.
Dick sang it like someone who knew this from the inside.
Like someone who had spent twenty-one years asking the question and had recently, finally, tentatively, found an answer.
The room understood this. The room understood it completely and immediately, because the thing Dick was singing about was not abstract—it was specific, it was personal, it was a thing that had happened to a real child in a real house and was now being held up in a concert hall of a space station with warmth and grief and the dignity of someone who had survived it and could look at it directly.
Barry had stopped hosting and was simply standing to the side of the stage with his hand over his mouth.
Diana had her arms folded across her chest, not in the defensive way, but in the way of someone holding themselves together.
Hal Jordan, who had last cried in public in approximately never, had given up on looking at the ceiling and was looking at the stage.
Wally's kids had stopped moving.
At the back table, Bruce sat completely still.
The song described a figure who was present and absent. Who gave presence of body without presence of self. Who left a child searching through the architecture of a house for the warmth that should have been there and wasn't. Who passed on silence when words were needed. Whose love was real and expressed in ways that hurt instead of held.
Dick wasn't singing about John Grayson.
Not only.
John Grayson had died. John Grayson hadn't had the chance to be absent — he'd been taken, catastrophically, all at once, which was its own grief and one Dick was also singing about, the loss that was total and sudden and left nothing to work with.
But there was another absence in this song. The kind that was worse, in certain ways, than the sudden kind—the slow kind, the kind that happened inside a presence, the kind where someone was there every day and still somehow not there, the kind of absence that a child spent years trying to explain to themselves and couldn't because he's right there, he has to love me, why does it feel like—
Bruce felt it land.
He didn't look away.
Selina's hand, still in his under the table, tightened.
He held on.
Dick sang.
He sang the child's question—where are you, where are you—and he sang it with his eyes open, moving between the middle distance and specific points in the room, and once, just briefly, his eyes found the back table.
Found Bruce.
And moved on.
Not with hatred. Not with anything that required a response. Just a look. A clear-eyed, direct, fully present acknowledgment that landed in Bruce's chest like a key in a lock.
I see you there. I know you're there. This is the truth of what happened and I'm saying it in a room full of people who love me and you're there and I'm okay.
Bruce didn't move.
Tim, beside him, was looking at the table.
Jason, across from him, was looking at the stage with the expression of a person who had not known this was coming and was experiencing something large and not attempting to manage it, which was its own form of progress.
Cass had her head slightly bowed.
Stephanie, who had been vibrating with uncertain energy all evening, had gone entirely still.
The song moved.
It moved through the loss and the searching and the specific quality of growing up in the shape of an absence, and then it turned—the way the best things turn, not falsely, not with a resolution that wasn't earned, but genuinely, with the weight of what had come before making the arrival somewhere real.
The finding.
Dick's voice did something different in this part. Not louder. Not more dramatic. Quieter, actually, which was the choice that cost the most and worked the best. He sang it like someone describing a private thing being made public for the first time, like someone saying something out loud that had been true for a while and was now finally ready to be said that way.
At the front table, Clark was crying.
Not quietly. Not with the restrained brightness of someone managing it, no—Clark Kent, who had faced things that had broken planets, was sitting in a chair in the Watchtower with his baby in his arms and his face completely open and tears running down it, not bothering to stop them, because what was happening on that stage was his son and there was nothing to do about what that felt like except let it be as large as it was.
In his arms, Lara had dozed off again.
Jon had both hands flat on the table and was looking at his brother on the stage with an expression that was fourteen years old and also very old and contained something that didn't have a name except this. This is the thing. This right here.
Lois was filming. Her hand was not entirely steady. Her face was doing what it did when Lois Lane was feeling something she hadn't consented to feel in a public setting, which was to look more focused than usual, as if intention alone could keep the rest of it in place.
It wasn't working.
Dick reached the end.
He reached the end of the song the way it was written — arriving somewhere, not triumphant, not dramatic, but landed. Present. The question answered, or not answered but dissolved, replaced by something better than an answer: the thing itself, found and held and real.
He let the last note go.
The room was silent for one full second.
Then he looked straight at Clark.
And said, in French, quiet enough that the microphone barely caught it and everyone heard it anyway: "Je t'ai trouvé."
I found you.
The room came apart.
It came apart in the good way—the noise of people who had been holding themselves together coming apart all at once, applause and something less ordered than applause, the specific sound of a room full of people who have been moved past their own management of it.
Scattered across different tables, the original Titans hooted and whistled, putting their all into celebrating their brother.
Lara, roused from her nap by all the noise, regarded her brother thoughtfully.
Jon grinned. Not the casual grin. The real one. The one that took up his whole face.
Clark was already moving.
He handed Lara to Jon without looking—Jon caught her and carefully supported her head like he’d been doing it the entire one and a half months of Lara’s existence—and he stood up and crossed the distance to the stage in the way Clark Kent moved when he'd stopped thinking about how he moved, which was to say quickly and with complete intention, and he stepped up onto the stage and Dick was already turning and Clark's arms were around him before Dick had fully registered what was happening.
Clark held him.
The way he held him. The way he always held him. One arm across his back and one hand in his hair and his face pressed to the side of Dick's head and the whole posture of someone who was not letting go anytime soon and not apologising for it.
Dick's arms came around him, holding on tightly.
The room received this with the warmth of people who understood what they were witnessing—not a performance, not a gesture, just two people who had found each other and were standing on a stage in front of a room full of heroes and their families and not caring, not remotely, because what was there between them was more than large enough to stand in the open.
Clark was saying something into Dick's hair.
Nobody heard it.
It wasn't for them.
At the front table, Lois put down her phone.
She'd stopped filming at je t'ai trouvé and then started again when Clark got up and stopped again when they were on the stage because some things one didn't film, and then she'd put the phone face-down and sat with Lara in her lap and Jon's hand covering hers on the table and let herself feel the full uncomplicated size of it.
She'd met Clark Kent twenty-two years ago.
She'd watched him be many things over those years—reporter, hero, husband, father. She'd watched him be reckless and brilliant and occasionally wrong and frequently infuriating and always, underneath all of it, the same person: someone who showed up. Someone who stayed. Someone who, when a person was carrying something alone that they didn't have to carry alone, went and got them.
She'd watched him become Dick's.
She'd watched it happen slowly and completely and with the particular logic of things that were always going to be true waiting for their conditions to arrive.
She sat in the Watchtower with her daughter in her lap and her son's hand over hers and watched her husband hold their boy on a stage in front of the Justice League and their families and cried, simply, without managing it, because this was one of those moments you were supposed to be in fully and she was fully in it.
Jon squeezed her hand.
She squeezed back.
At the back table, Bruce sat with the aftermath of the song.
The room was noise and warmth now, Clark and Dick still on the stage, the applause settling into the general movement of an evening after something significant, people turning to each other, the natural recalibration of a room that had been moved and was now moving gently back toward itself.
Bruce sat still.
Selina hadn't said anything. Neither had Tim. Neither had Jason.
Jason was looking at the stage. His jaw was set and his eyes were wet and he was doing absolutely nothing about this, which was its own kind of statement.
Tim had his hands folded on the table and was looking at them.
Cass had looked at Bruce once, briefly, with her clear eyes and the language she spoke without words, and then looked back at the stage.
Stephanie, beside him, made a sound that was almost a breath and said, very quietly, "God."
"I know," Bruce said.
He'd not looked away.
He'd watched all of it — Dick's voice, the song, the turn, the words in French. He'd watched Clark on his feet before the note had finished. He'd watched Dick's face when Clark's arms came around him, the expression that crossed it in the half-second before he disappeared into the embrace: the expression of someone arriving somewhere they'd been moving toward for a very long time.
He'd watched.
He hadn't looked away.
He thought about a boy of eight with a gap-toothed smile who had arrived at Wayne Manor twenty-one years ago holding a stuffed elephant to his chest.
He thought about Dick's eyes finding the back table and moving on. Not with hatred. With something more precise than hatred and harder to bear: with the clear-eyed sight of someone who had done the work of understanding what had happened and had moved through it to somewhere else. Not forgiven—Dick hadn't forgiven him and Bruce did not expect him to and would not ask him to. But through. Out the other side. Into the life that was his now, the life with Clark and Lois and Jon and Lara and Kory and Roy and Donna and Wally and the children at the gym.
Je t'ai trouvé.
I found you.
Bruce looked at his hands.
He looked at them for a long moment.
Then Selina's hand turned his over and held it, and he let her, and he lifted his eyes to the stage where his son was still held by the man who deserved to hold him, and he stayed in it. Stayed with the full uncomplicated crushing weight of it. Didn't cut it short, didn't qualify it, didn't find a way to make it smaller.
The consequence.
The thing that was good and cost everything and was still good.
He stayed with it until he could hold it without it stopping his breath.
He looked at Jason across the table.
Jason was looking back at him. His eyes were dry now. His jaw was still set. He looked like someone who had sat with his family at the back of a room and watched something difficult and remained, and was watching Bruce to see if Bruce would also remain.
Bruce remained.
Jason nodded once. The smallest possible nod. The kind that didn't concede anything and said everything.
Bruce nodded back.
On the stage, Clark was saying something to Dick and Dick laughed—the surprised one, the real one, the one that caught him off guard—and Clark's hand was in his hair and the room was warm and full and the flowers were still on every table and the children were clapping again for no current reason except that they wanted to.
Bruce looked at all of it.
He kept looking.
This was the consequence. This was what accountability looked like when you did it without looking away.
His son, found.
By someone who knew how.
Bruce stayed until the end of the evening. He did not approach Dick. Dick did not approach him. They existed in the same room for the first time in over a year and that was what it was and it was enough and it was not enough and both of those things were true.
He went home with Selina's hand in his.
He didn't sleep for a long time.
But he'd stayed.
He'd stayed and he hadn't looked away.
In the end, he thought, that was what tonight had required.
He'd done it.
It was not enough.
It was a start.