Actions

Work Header

Thou Shalt Lead (And I Will Follow) (A Companion to The Seven Gates)

Summary:

Maedhros and Maglor rekindle their trust after Thangorodrim, the Long Peace and the Dagor Bragollach. Mostly set between Chapter 30 and 38 of The Seven Gates.

Notes:

This is a collection of short scenes/conversations between Maedhros and Maglor, set between the Dagor Bragollach and the Nirnaeth Arnoediad. 'Thou Shalt Lead' is a companion piece to 'The Seven Gates' (my soon 200K+ canon gapfiller on the Union of Maedhros and the Nirnaeth) -- but you can read it as a standalone fic as well.
The chapters are named after daily prompts from the Maedhros & Maglor Week 2025 Tumblr event -- they follow them quite loosely, but there is always some connection.

Some background info if you want to read this without 'The Seven Gates': At the beginning of 'Gates', the relationship between Maedhros and Maglor is strained. Having lost his lands and most of his men in the Bragollach (generally referred to as 'The Flames'), Maglor keeps disregarding his personal safety and taking rash actions. He reaches a breaking point in Chapter 30, revealing that he has been, for centuries, silently struggling with guilt for having abandoned Maedhros in his captivity, and then seeing him become the greatest enemy of Morgoth. After this revelation, their relationship gradually becomes close again, but it is no longer central to the plot of 'Gates' -- hence the inspiration for 'Thou Shalt Lead' :)
Although Maedhros and Maglor seemingly resolve their conflict in Chapter 30 of 'Gates', it all resurfaces when Maedhros learns that his counsellor and close friend (Tyelcano, an OC) was probably captured by the Enemy - and proceeds to do the exact opposite of what he had previously told Maglor a good leader must do. This subplot was entirely left out of 'Gates' because slow and scattered as it is, the main plot just did not leave room for it.

On names: Maedhros's POV sometimes uses shortened Quenya names for his brothers; in 'Gates', 'Kano' always refers to Maglor (and not Fingon), 'Tyelko' to Celegorm and 'Tyel' to his OC counsellor, Tyelcano. The rest, I think, is quite straightforward.
'The Warden of the East' is a title that Maedhros has in 'Gates': he earned it when he defended the Himring in the Bragollach.

Chapter 1: Day 1: Children

Notes:

Set a few days after the events in 'The Lord of the Gap'.

Chapter Text

Moryo is occupied with the watch today. Guard-posts need to be remanned, all weaponry assessed and new trade agreements with the Dwarves are to be hatched.

Tyelko is occupied with the scouts. Orcs still linger in the wastelands, and chasing them is the closest thing to hunting he can think of; so he gathers the remnants of his pride and leaves, ready to kill.

Curvo has locked himself in the smithy. Smoke rises from the smelters and there is much to do: the Flames had left the defenders of the Himring weary and broken, their armour beaten and tattered, their weapons blunted, their armoury empty.

Pityo and Telvo have left for Doriath. There is little hope of Thingol even receiving them, and they shall likely return without reply, or worse; still, a message has to be sent about the stolen Silmaril; and if anyone could find a way through that forest of peril and guile, it is them.

Findekáno has probably risen with the sun, and ridden out with Tyelko; and now he must be getting ready for the journey ahead.

And Tyelcano is dead, or worse - which leaves Maedhros alone with his eldest brother.


"You are going to war, are you not?"

The question whizzes across the breakfast table, the arrowhead of accusation hitting target with ruthless precision.

He draws a breath to reply, but Kano has aimed for the throat.

"...the question remains," he continues, slender fingers playing with the jewels on his cup, "whether you wished to hide it from me, or you deemed it mere evidence."

As simple as the answers to these questions seem to be (yes, the Warden of the East is indeed going to war; and no, it has not even occurred to him to hide it), he still chokes on the words. Nothing is ever that straightforward with Kano: he sees meanings within meanings, interpretations within different realities, implications of astonishing insight that only time can prove justified.

Is he, in fact, going to war?

Is he, in fact, trying to hide it?

"I find myself torn, if you care to know," Maedhros says. "There is what my heart tells me to do, what good reason guides me to avoid, and what duty pushes me to achieve."

"Yet you find that those three things have met at some point," says Kano with valuable insight, "and so you have, in your heart, decided. To war you shall go: unwilling as you are to call it war, for your men are tired, your lands reclaimed not so long ago, and the peace you have fought for still fragile. Yet alas - your wrath, once kindled, is not so easily forgotten."

He looks almost proud of himself as he sits there, clutching the empty cup, eyes bright and wide, as if they were still living the noontide of Tirion over the Sea, before their brothers were born. Even then, Kano would read him like an open book, right from the very spring of his youth.

Maedhros used to laugh, and call him insufferable; but now he has forgotten how to laugh, and is unsure how to call him.

"You do, in fact, know me very well."

Kano averts his eyes.

"Still you would tell me nothing."

"As I said: I am torn."

"Do you not know yourself the way I know you, Nelyo? Of course you shall go, and avenge your counsellor - he is a close friend to you, even if you care not to admit it -, and lay the Orcs to ruin and make them fear your name once more. Why would you have any doubt about this?"

"This is not what makes me uncertain," Maedhros says softly. "I must also decide who shall be Regent in my stead. According to all reason, I should make you sit in my seat in the Himring and lead while I am gone; and send Carnistir to Belegost to continue his dealings with the Dwarves. And yet..."

"And yet you do not trust me enough, after all my failings and losses," Kano says bitterly.

"...and yet I wish not to be apart from you any more," says Maedhros.

They look at each other over the table, astonished; and it suddenly feels as though they were still sitting on the shores of Lake Helevorn, with the smoke of funeral pyres rising above the water, their garments black with dried blood.

It was easy to feel close to each other then, with no witnesses other than the summer sun and the silent lake. Now it is much harder to cross the careful distance between them, made comfortable by four centuries of peace; and then decades of utter turmoil.

Kano reaches for his hand above the table, and squeezes it.

"I shall come with you and Findekáno to the West, if upon your departure, you still so wish," he says, "and if peril shall come out of it, we must see it through."