Work Text:
It started with petals.
Small ones, at first. The kind you could dismiss. The kind that arrived at the back of the throat like a tickle, like the beginning of something that would pass if you drank enough water and got enough sleep and stopped looking at Manon's hands when she sketched and stopped memorizing the specific way Sophia said her name in the morning, soft and unguarded, before the day had fully arrived.
Yoonchae dismissed them for three weeks.
She was good at dismissing things. She had spent her whole life developing this particular skill — the ability to look at something true and say not now to it, to fold it carefully and place it somewhere dark where it could not do damage. She had dismissed the moment she first understood what she felt for Manon — the specific afternoon six months ago when Manon had been sketching and Yoonchae had looked at the angle of her wrist and thought oh with the quality of an oh that had no good answer attached to it. She had dismissed the moment she understood what she felt for Sophia — the morning three months ago when Sophia had said something that made her laugh and then looked at her like the laugh was the best thing in the room and Yoonchae had thought oh again with the same quality.
Two ohs. Both unasked for. Both completely impossible.
Because Manon and Sophia had each other.
Had each other in the specific visible way of two people who had found the person who completed the shape of them — the way they existed in rooms together, the ease of it, the particular quality of their closeness that was not performed for anyone because it didn't need to be performed, it was simply true. Yoonchae had watched it for months and loved them both for it and hated herself slightly for loving them both for it.
On the twenty-second day she coughed into a tissue in the bathroom at two in the morning and looked at what was there and could not dismiss it anymore.
White. Small. Shaped like something she couldn't immediately name.
She folded the tissue carefully.
She washed her hands.
She went back to bed and lay in the dark and listened to the apartment breathe around her and thought: so this is what this is.
The nights were the worst of it.
Not because the disease was worse at night — it was indifferent to the time, arrived at its own schedule without consulting her — but because the nights were when the work stopped and the performances stopped and the specific exhausting business of being a person in the world stopped, and in that stopping there was nothing left to put between her and the feelings she had been managing all day.
She lay in her room and the darkness had a texture.
She thought about Manon's sketchbook on the kitchen table in the mornings, left open to whatever she'd been working on the night before. The specific quality of her concentration — the way the world simply ceased to exist for her when she was drawing, the way you could say her name twice before she heard it, the way the third time she looked up with an expression that was emerging from somewhere deep and private and the emergence of it was one of the most beautiful things Yoonchae had ever witnessed.
She thought about Sophia's voice in the hallway at seven AM, already talking to someone, already arranging the day. The particular competence of her. The way she moved through complexity with the ease of someone for whom complexity had always been the water she swam in. The way she looked at Yoonchae sometimes — direct and warm and specific, the look of someone who saw you rather than the version of you they'd decided on.
She lay in the dark and thought about both of them and felt the petals build at the back of her throat like a tide that did not care about timetables.
She had started sleeping with a glass of water on the nightstand and tissues within reach because the coughing came at unpredictable hours and she had learned to manage it quietly.
Quietly was everything.
She was keeping this secret with the specific ferocity of someone who understood exactly what would happen if it wasn't kept — the look on their faces, the guilt of it, the way love given in response to a disease was not love given freely and she would rather die than receive love that was not given freely.
She would rather die.
She was beginning to understand this was not a figure of speech.
She pressed her hand against her sternum.
She looked at the ceiling.
She thought: does the night hear the words I speak? Because I have been speaking them for months into the dark and I do not know where they go, and if they go nowhere then I am keeping them entirely inside myself and they are becoming flowers and the flowers are becoming everything and I do not know how much of this I have left.
There was a page Yoonchae had seen by accident.
She had not meant to look. She had been passing through the kitchen in the early morning, heading to the kettle, and had glanced at the open sketchbook on the table.
The page was a study in hands.
Specifically her hands.
She had recognized them with the immediate certainty of someone confronted with themselves unexpectedly — the specific shape of her fingers, the particular way she held things, rendered in Manon's careful lines with the attention Manon gave to things she found worth looking at closely.
She had stood in the kitchen and looked at the drawing for a long moment.
Then she had gone to the kettle and made her tea and gone back to her room and sat on the edge of her bed and pressed her own hands flat against her thighs and felt the petals climbing.
It was not a romantic drawing.
She understood this. Manon drew things she found interesting — shapes, angles, the geometry of the world rendered in pencil. The drawing was not a declaration. It was Manon doing what Manon did, which was find the world worth looking at carefully.
But it was her hands.
Manon had sat somewhere in the apartment and looked at her hands long enough to learn them that well. Had looked at her and found something worth the attention.
This was not the same as what she felt.
She knew that.
She coughed into her tissue and looked at the white petals and knew that, and the knowing of it did not help, and she had stopped expecting knowing things to help.
There was a moment Yoonchae kept returning to.
She returned to it the way you return to something that is both unbearable and necessary — the specific compulsion of a person who cannot look away from the thing that is destroying them.
An ordinary evening. Manon in the corner with her sketchbook, Sophia at the table with something work-related, Yoonchae on the couch with a book she was not reading.
Sophia got up to get something from the kitchen.
She paused in the doorway.
She looked back at Manon in the corner with the sketchbook and her expression had been—
Yoonchae had seen that expression.
It was the expression of someone looking at the thing they love most in the world in an unguarded moment, when they do not know they are being watched, when there is no performance in it, just the pure simple fact of the feeling, which was enormous and complete and left absolutely no room for anything else.
Sophia had looked at Manon like that.
And then she had continued to the kitchen.
And Yoonchae had sat on the couch with her unread book and understood, very clearly and very completely, the geometry of the situation she was in.
She loved them both.
They loved each other.
She was the third point of a shape that had no room for a third point.
She had coughed quietly into her hand that evening and excused herself early and gone to her room and sat in the dark for a long time.
She had not turned the light on.
She had sat in the specific darkness of a person who has understood something they cannot ununderstand and does not yet know what to do with the weight of it.
She sat there for hours.
The flowers grew.
She looked it up.
White camellia.
You're the most beautiful. That was what it meant, in the old language that nobody spoke anymore. You're the most beautiful and I am dying of it.
She had sat with her phone and looked at the photograph of the white camellia and thought: yes. That is accurate. That is very specifically accurate.
She had put her phone down and coughed and looked at the white petals in her hand and thought: at least it's a beautiful flower.
This was a thing she could do — find the precise angle of something true and look at it with the specific quality of appreciation she had for things that were beautifully made, even when the thing that was beautifully made was her own undoing.
She was dying of the most beautiful flowers.
She was dying of the specific beauty of two people who were not hers and whom she loved anyway, who she had loved without asking their permission or her own, who she would keep loving in the specific way she had always loved — quietly, in the dark, with the petals building in her chest like a garden that was growing in the wrong place.
Even the moon comes to seduce, she thought, looking at the ceiling.
And here I am, seduced by two people who don't know it, who are seducing no one, who are simply existing and being themselves and that is enough, that has always been more than enough, that is in fact the problem.
The walls of the apartment were not thin enough.
Yoonchae had been careful. More careful than she had ever been careful about anything — timing the coughing for showers, for times when the apartment was empty, for the deepest part of the night when sleep made everyone deaf to ordinary sounds.
She had thought they were asleep.
She had thought it was safe.
She had coughed — not the managed quiet version, not the controlled single-cough she had developed for dangerous hours, but the real version, the one her body had been building toward all day, the one that arrived with the force of something that had been held back too long. It lasted longer than the manageable kind. It produced more petals than the manageable kind. It sounded like someone drowning, quietly, in a room at the end of a hallway.
She did not hear the soft sound outside her door.
She did not know that Manon had been awake. That Manon, who slept lightly, had heard something pull her out of sleep with the alert specific quality of someone who has heard something that requires investigation.
She did not know that Manon stood outside her door for a long moment.
She did not know that Manon's hand came up to the wood of it and rested there and then did not knock.
She did not know any of this.
She folded her tissues and put them in the small bag she kept under her bed and she lay back against her pillow and breathed carefully and looked at the ceiling.
In the hallway, Manon stood with her palm flat against the door.
On the other side of the door, Yoonchae lay in the dark and breathed and did not know.
Manon stood there for a very long time.
Then she went back to bed.
She lay beside Sophia and looked at the ceiling.
"You're awake," Sophia said, without opening her eyes.
"Yes," Manon said.
"Why."
A pause that was longer than the question required.
"I thought I heard something," Manon said.
Sophia opened her eyes. She looked at the ceiling. She looked at Manon's face in the dark.
"Is everything okay," Sophia said.
Manon looked at the ceiling.
"I don't know," she said.
The thing about being loved that Yoonchae had not anticipated was that it was its own kind of unbearable.
Not the love she felt for them, which was unbearable in the way of loving without return, the way of a fire with nowhere to go. That unbearable she had prepared for. That unbearable she had learned to carry.
The other kind. The being loved kind.
Because they loved her.
This was the specific cruelty of it — that she had not chosen people who were indifferent to her. They saw her. They loved her. They loved her in every way that was not the way she needed.
Sophia noticed when she was tired and made her tea without being asked.
Manon saved her a seat by habit, the unconscious memory of where Yoonchae preferred to sit, by the window, where the light was best.
They both looked at her when she spoke with the attention of people who had decided that what she said was worth listening to completely.
They laughed at the right things. They were quiet in the right ways. They existed beside her with the easy warmth of people who genuinely wanted her there and showed it in every small unconscious way that meant everything and cost her everything.
She was loved completely in every way except the one that mattered.
This was, she thought, a very specific and sophisticated form of torture.
She sat at the table and felt them love her and felt the petals and said ordinary things and thought: where are you, my beloved, where are you in the version of this where I am allowed to say it.
Does the night hear the words I speak.
Because I have been speaking them for months into the dark of my room and I do not know where they go. And if they go nowhere then they stay inside me. And if they stay inside me they become this. And this is becoming everything.
She wrote it down.
Not to be found. Not as communication. She wrote it down the way you let blood from a wound that is not going to be treated — not to fix it but to relieve the specific pressure of it, to give it somewhere to go other than the inside of her chest where it was competing with the flowers for space.
She wrote:
I love you in the way that flowers grow in lungs — without being asked, without being wanted, taking up space that belongs to breathing.
She wrote:
I have memorized the sound of your voice saying my name. I play it in the dark the way other people play music. I do not think I decided to do this. I think it simply began happening and I discovered it too late to stop it.
She wrote:
Perhaps even through the bloods of my lungs, words cannot profess the love I've tortured myself in. Perhaps this is what hanahaki is — not the flowers exactly, but the impossibility of language in the face of something too large for it. The body doing what the mouth cannot. The body saying: look, look at what you have made of me, look at what I have grown in the absence of being able to say it.
She wrote:
You are both irreplaceable. I know you know this about each other. I know you look at each other and understand with the complete conviction of people who have found the specific thing they were looking for. I know this because I have watched you know it, which is its own specific form of beauty, which is something I would not have missed for anything including my own survival, which is perhaps why I am not surviving.
She wrote:
I am not angry. I want to be clear about that. I am not angry at you for loving each other or at myself for loving you or at the universe for the geometry of this. I am just tired. I am so tired of the quiet. I am so tired of the folded tissues. I am so tired of being a person entirely composed of unsaid things.
She wrote:
Where are you, my beloved. Where are you in the version of this where I arrive.
She folded the paper into the smallest possible square.
She put it under the bag of petals.
She looked at the ceiling.
She did not sleep.
The progression was not dramatic.
This was the cruelest part. She had expected it to be dramatic — had expected some clear line between manageable and not, some event that would mark the transition. Instead it was the undramatic accumulation of small changes. The coughing lasting slightly longer each week. The petals slightly more numerous. The tightness in her chest more present in the hours when it had previously been absent.
She ate less.
This was not intentional. Her appetite had simply relocated itself somewhere she could not find it.
She slept less.
The nighttime coughing made this impossible to avoid.
She became, she noticed in the bathroom mirror, slightly less. Slightly thinner. Slightly more shadowed in the specific places where exhaustion settled in a face. She looked at herself and thought: I look like someone with flowers in their lungs. Which was accurate. Which was the most specific kind of accurate there was.
She got better at hiding it.
This was the skill set that developed in the second month — the precise calibration of energy expenditure, the exact amount of animation required to read as fine, the specific timing of excusing herself that appeared natural rather than escape. She became very practiced at looking like someone who was simply tired.
Sophia made her tea more often.
Manon saved her the window seat every morning now, not occasionally, every morning, without comment, without drawing attention to the saving of it, just the seat available and warm when Yoonchae arrived.
She accepted both things with the grace of someone receiving love they cannot hold.
A gentle whisper is heard in my long night, my love, she thought, watching Manon's pencil move across the page. But I am the only one whispering. And the night does not answer. And the flowers are getting louder.
There was a day when Sophia looked at her for too long.
Just the two of them in the kitchen. Sophia mid-sentence about something ordinary. Yoonchae listening with the full attention she could not make less than full.
She had laughed at something Sophia said.
Sophia stopped.
Mid-sentence, completely stopped, and looked at Yoonchae with an expression that had a quality she did not know how to read without wanting it to mean something it was not allowed to mean. Something that was arriving somewhere. Something that had been traveling for a while and had not yet announced its destination.
"What," Yoonchae said.
"Nothing," Sophia said. And then: "You look—"
She stopped.
"I look what," Yoonchae said.
Sophia shook her head. Resumed the sentence.
Yoonchae listened to the rest of it and laughed in the right places and asked a question and the moment passed.
But she sat with it afterward.
She sat with you look— and its unfinished ending and she turned it over and looked at all its sides and eventually she put it down because picking it up was not survivable.
She had a limited number of things she could afford to examine directly.
The stopped look in Sophia's kitchen was not one of them.
She coughed into her hand that evening and the petals were larger than they had been the week before.
She noted this.
She filed it.
She said nothing.
There was a night when she almost said it.
They were on the couch. All three of them — the comfortable arrangement of an ordinary evening, Manon with her sketchbook, Sophia with something she was reading, Yoonchae in the middle with her legs folded and her head tilted slightly back against the cushion, looking at the ceiling.
It was late. The city outside had quieted. The apartment was warm and the lamp was on and it was the specific kind of ordinary beautiful evening that she had been storing up like provisions for a winter she could feel coming.
Yoonchae was looking at the ceiling and thinking about white camellias and the specific geometry of a love that had no room for her and she was so tired, she was so specifically tired, and the petals were there in the back of her throat in the particular heavy way they were in the evenings, and she thought:
I could say it.
I could just say it. I could say I love you both in the specific way that is killing me and I could let it be outside of me and maybe the flowers would stop if it was outside of me.
She thought about the look on their faces if she said it.
She thought about the guilt that would appear there, because she knew them, she knew their guilt, she knew that Sophia's guilt moved through her quickly and completely and Manon's settled more slowly and went deeper and stayed, and she knew that they would look at her with that guilt and say something and try to fix it, and the trying would be love but it would be love in response to her dying and she would rather the flowers take everything before she received love that was born from obligation to her disease.
She thought: no.
She thought: not like this. Not ever like this. I will not make my dying their burden. I will not let the last thing I give them be guilt.
The petals built in her throat.
She swallowed.
"I'm going to bed," she said.
"It's early," Sophia said.
"I'm tired," she said.
Sophia looked at her. The focused specific look.
"Okay," Sophia said. "Sleep well."
Manon looked up from her sketchbook.
Her expression was the careful reading one. The one that meant she was looking at something and trying to understand it and was close, was very close, to understanding it.
"Yoonchae," she said.
"Mm," Yoonchae said, already standing.
Manon held her gaze for a moment that lasted longer than moments usually lasted.
"Sleep well," she said finally. And the way she said it had something in it. Some quality. Some weight that was not in the words themselves but in the specific way she placed them.
Yoonchae went to her room.
She coughed for twenty minutes.
She lay on the floor of her bathroom because the cold tiles were better than the bed and she pressed her cheek against them and breathed and thought: where are you, my beloved. I am twenty feet away and twenty feet has never been so far and I am so tired of the distance I have chosen and I would choose it again because the alternative is making you carry me and I love you too much to make you carry me.
She got up off the floor.
She went to bed.
She said nothing.
It happened on a Tuesday morning.
She had not planned it. She had not woken up and thought: today is the day I will let something slip. She had woken up with the specific exhaustion of someone who had spent the night losing ground to something relentless, and she had gotten dressed with the careful movements of someone who is rationing energy, and she had come to the kitchen because they were there and she wanted to see them and she was running out of mornings to see them in.
She had sat down at the table.
Sophia had made coffee. Three cups, the way she always did, each one specific to its person. She slid Yoonchae's across without looking up from her phone, which was the specific intimacy of someone who has made coffee for another person so many times it has become reflex, has become something done without thought, which was its own specific kind of love and which was going to be the thing that broke Yoonchae today, she could feel it.
Manon was at her usual place with her sketchbook.
The morning was quiet.
It was so ordinary. That was the thing — it was so profoundly ordinary, the table and the coffee and the sketchbook and the morning light, and she was sitting in the middle of it and she was so full of flowers she could feel them when she breathed, could feel the specific weight of all the growing things in her chest, and she was so tired and so grateful and so devastated by all of it simultaneously.
She opened her mouth.
She meant to say something ordinary.
She meant to say something about the weather or the schedule or some other ordinary navigable thing, something that would get her through this morning the way she had gotten through all the other mornings.
What came out was:
"Perhaps even through the bloods of my lungs," she said, "words cannot profess the love I've tortured myself in."
Her own voice surprised her.
It came out very quiet. Very even. Like something that had been waiting behind her teeth for a very long time and had found, in the specific exhaustion of this particular morning, a gap in the management.
The kitchen went completely still.
Sophia looked up from her phone.
Manon's pencil stopped.
The silence was the specific silence of a room in which something irreversible has just been said.
Yoonchae looked at her coffee cup.
She looked at her hands around it, which were Manon's hands in the sketchbook, which were the hands she had been coughing flowers over for months, and she thought: there it is. There it finally is. Outside of me. In the air. Irretrievable.
She did not look at them.
She could not look at them.
"Yoonchae," Sophia said. Her voice had a quality it did not usually have. Something that had moved very quickly from ordinary morning to somewhere else.
"I'm—" Yoonchae started.
She coughed.
It was not the managed kind.
She had no managed kind left this morning, she had spent all her managed kind in the night, she was operating on nothing, and the cough came out of her the way things come out of people who have run out of capacity to contain them — fully, completely, with the specific force of weeks of restraint behind it.
She pressed her hand over her mouth.
She felt the petals against her palm.
She pulled her hand away and looked at it and the white camellias were there, small and perfect and unmistakable, sitting in the center of her palm in the kitchen where they had all had a thousand ordinary mornings together.
She closed her fingers around them.
She looked up.
They were both looking at her.
And the look on their faces —
The look on their faces was the thing she had known would be there and had spent months trying to prevent, had organized her entire secret around preventing, had been willing to die quietly and privately and alone to prevent.
It was there anyway.
"How long," Manon said.
Her voice was very quiet.
Yoonchae looked at the table.
"Yoonchae." Sophia's voice. A different quality in it now, something that was not professional, not managed, something that was just Sophia stripped of everything except the specific fear of someone who has understood something and does not want it to be true. "How long."
Yoonchae opened her fingers.
She looked at the white camellias in her palm.
"They're very beautiful," she said. "That's the thing I keep coming back to. That it's a beautiful flower." She looked at it. "I looked it up. White camellia." A pause. "It means: you're the most beautiful. Which is accurate. Which is exactly accurate."
"Yoonchae," Manon said.
"I'm sorry," Yoonchae said. She was not crying. She had decided not to cry about this and she was holding to that decision even now, even here. "I'm sorry, I didn't mean for that to — I was going to be more careful. I've been more careful than this."
"How long," Sophia said again.
"Months," Yoonchae said. Simply. Factually.
The word landed in the kitchen like something physical.
"Months," Sophia said.
"Since—" Yoonchae stopped. "It doesn't matter since when. It matters that I didn't tell you and I should explain that. I should explain why." She looked at the flowers in her hand. "I couldn't tell you because of what you would do. Because of what would appear on your faces." She still wasn't looking at them. "The look that is currently on your faces. I knew it would be there and I couldn't — I didn't want love that was born from obligation to my disease. I didn't want to be the thing that you loved because you had to. Because I was dying and you couldn't stand to let me die without—"
Her voice stopped.
She pressed her lips together.
She looked at the white camellias.
"I have been so careful," she said, and her voice was very small now. "I have been so careful with the tissues and the timing and the—I was going to manage this. I was going to manage it until there was nothing left to manage and I was going to do it without making it your problem." She looked at the flowers. "I'm sorry. I'm sorry that I failed at that this morning. I'm sorry that you have to see this now."
The kitchen was completely silent.
"You were going to die," Manon said. Her voice had a quality Yoonchae had never heard in it before — something beneath the careful reading one, something that was not reading at all but just responding, just the raw unmediated response of a person receiving something they cannot process. "You were going to die and you were going to let us not know."
"Yes," Yoonchae said.
"Because you didn't want to burden us," Sophia said.
"Because I didn't want love you gave me out of guilt," Yoonchae said. "There's a difference. I was very specific about the reason."
Another silence.
She closed her hand around the petals.
"Perhaps," she said, quietly, to the table, to the coffee cup, to the small white flowers that had been growing in her lungs since the autumn, "perhaps even through the bloods of my lungs, words cannot profess the love I've tortured myself in." She paused. "Perhaps the night has been keeping them for me. Perhaps—"
Her voice gave out.
She stopped.
She pressed her closed fist against her sternum and felt the flowers and felt the specific weight of all the months of the night and the quiet and the folded tissues and the managed coughs and the unread book and the seat by the window and the coffee made the way she took it.
She pressed her fist against her sternum.
She looked at the table.
"I'm sorry," she said. "I'm so sorry. I was only trying not to be a burden. I was only trying to love you in a way that didn't cost you anything."
She heard the sound of a chair.
She heard the sound of Manon's sketchbook closing.
She felt a hand against the back of her neck — warm and specific and there, completely there — and she closed her eyes.
She did not know which one of them it was.
It did not matter which one of them it was.
She sat at the kitchen table with the white camellias in her closed fist and a warm hand at the back of her neck and two years of silence pressing against the inside of her throat alongside the flowers, and she thought:
My night has no light.
My dreams surely aren't beautiful.
They have no meaning, they feel ruined.
Where are you, my beloved.
My beloved.
Does the night hear the words I speak.
She thought: yes. It does. It has been hearing them all along. It just could not answer. It just kept them for me, in the dark, where they could not do damage.
Perhaps that is enough.
Perhaps that will have to be enough.
She sat at the table and held the flowers and said nothing else.
Outside, the morning continued.
The light came through the windows.
The coffee grew cold.
The sketchbook lay closed on the table for the first time in months.
And the white camellias were small and perfect in her hand, and they were very beautiful, and they were killing her, and she had loved them both completely and without asking for anything in return, and that was the truest thing she had.
That was the truest thing she had ever had.