Work Text:
Guy Gardner, for once in what seemed like forever, was both happy and excited. He'd been out on a mission for the Corps in deep space, handling a crisis of an invasive species on some alien planet with creatures the size of mice. It was an interesting mission, to say the least.
The reason why Guy was happy was for something only somewhat related to the mission. He was actually getting to visit Kyle while he was at the Watchtower. Guy had a few days off, why not spend it with Kyle back on Earth? He was sure they could have lots of fun together.
"Oh, Kyle~. Guess who's back?" Guy threw the door open to Kyle's workspace with a grin, expecting the fellow Lantern to be hard at work. Instead, he's greeted with someone he wasn't expecting at all. Plastic Man- Plas, for short- leers in front of him, one eye of his goggles raised as if he was raising a brow. "... Plas. What are you doing here? Bothering Kyle, like always?"
"How dare you!" Eel gasped and covered his heart with a hand, wriggling his body in distress. "That hurts, Guy! How could you think that? Me, bothering Kyle? I would never!"
"Oh, whatever. Don't lie to my face, dickwad." Guy shoved past the wiggly mess that was Eel, stepping up to Kyle instead, who was working away. He looked up when Guy approached, giving him a smile. "Hey, Kyle. Miss me?"
"Of course I did-"
"Nope, he didn't. Not at all. Personal space, please?" Eel pushed Guy's chest to force him back from the desk, practically wedging himself between Guy and Kyle. This didn't exactly go over perfectly for Guy, who immediately stiffened up and squared his shoulders to appear a little more intimidating. Eel only chuckled. "Awe. You look soooo scary, Guy. I'm terrified!"
As Eel mimicked "The Scream" painting, Guy grasped his neck and quickly flung him aside, using his ring to form a structure around the annoying stretchy hero. When he finally had a little silence in the room, he noticed Kyle looking a little… displeased with him. "What's that look for? I couldn't even get a damned word in with you thanks to him. He's always so loud.. "
"You didn't have to throw him around." Kyle sighed, standing up and shutting off what he was working on. "So, since you've locked Plas away.. I did miss you. What brings you back to the Watchtower? I thought you were on that mission with the… Oh, what were they called again? Eh, whatever. The planet with the tiny people."
"They were called Blites. I finished that mission up and since I did so well, they sent me home. I've got some time off, ain't that swell?" Guy crossed his arms, almost as if he was trying to show off how jacked his biceps were, flexing just a bit. Kyle didn't seem too interested at the moment. "Figured I would spend it with you. And.. I guess that goon too."
Guy reluctantly let Eel out of the Lantern construct. He was now just in his regular human shape, pouty and with his arms crossed. Guy rolled his eyes as Eel huffed and puffed his way over to the two, standing a bit taller than Guy without even using his abilities to grow.
"I cannot believe you just locked me up like that! No respect! Besides, Kyle should be spending time with me. All you're gonna do is be grumpy and angry the entire time and drag the mood down." Eel shoved his finger into Guy's chest where it pathetically bent like rubber rather than doing anything to Guy like intended. "So back to your little intergalactic mission and out of our hair."
"That's just gold, comin' from you , Eel. You're the one always buggin' everyone else because you're useless." Eel flinched back from that comment as Guy somehow managed to seem bigger and more threatening, his voice spitting venom. "You really think he wants to spend time with you, when all you are is a constant annoyance to everyone? C'mon, Plas. Be realistic."
"Guy, Eel, would you two quit?" Kyle's request fell on deaf ears as the two continued to bicker back and forth, the volume rising and the threat of an actual fight growing bigger as they kept yelling and shoving as if that was going to help. " Boys. Listen to me!"
Once again ignored, Kyle sighed. He'd have to take matters into his own hands, it seemed. With a wave of the hand with his ring, he pulled the two apart and snapped a muzzle over the both of them, finally getting their loud insults and angry shouting to pipe down. Eel deflated when he realized how angry Kyle really was, but Guy didn't change in the slightest. He was still pissed, and fuming even more now that Kyle had muzzled him.
"You two are being ridiculous. You're two grown men, and you shouldn't be having shoving matches because you can't get along. It is literal bullshit. " Kyle scoffed, crossing his arms and shaking his head in disbelief. Eel and Guy fighting over him. What has the world come to? The universe trusts in those two idiots to keep them protected? God… "If you two are going to keep acting like this, then neither of you will get to spend any time with me. Figure your shit out. I'm tired of dealing with you man-babies."
With another disappointed shake of his head, Kyle made his way out of the room, extinguishing the constructs holding Guy and Eel. They both stood there for a moment, looking to the door, before blinking stupidly at each other. The silence was both awkward and deafening. After a few beats of the weird amalgamation of silence, Guy was the first to speak up.
" Now look at what you've done. You've gone and pissed him off. What are we supposed to do now?"
Plas scoffed. " Me? It wasn't me who made him mad! You're the one who instigated it in the first place-"
Much too soon after Kyle's leaving, the two dissolved into more bickering, this time over whose fault it was that Kyle left upset. Instead of figuring it out and going to apologize, they let their jealousy get the best of them.
It was all rather pointless.
A few days passed, and nothing had really changed. Eel and Guy came home at separate times to an apartment devoid of one Kyle Rayner, leaving them both sitting with an empty feeling. They did their best to avoid each other, which was rather difficult considering they shared a bed. Eel found himself more often than not sleeping on the couch since Guy just had to take up the near entirety of the bed. It was almost a little ironic.
They spent the first week in this odd way of living together. What was normal from before was gone, and now they had to adjust to fighting and being together and missing one crucial person in their lives. This accumulated in more fighting, of course. Guy found himself constantly on edge, and instead of somewhat enjoying Eel's presence like he did before the whole ordeal, he couldn't stand to be around him now. No matter what happened, sparks flew.
Eel forgot to buy milk on the weekly grocery run. That dissolved into a fight, with Guy blaming Eel for being forgetful and not really caring about what he was doing when out and about. Of course, Eel thought this was ridiculous! He had a very scribbled list from Guy's handwriting and he couldn't even read it, so obviously it was Guy's fault for having shitty handwriting!
Meanwhile, Guy had a bad habit of leaving his dirty dishes throughout the apartment. Eel constantly complained about having to pick up his mess, even more so when he found Guy's dirty socks laying around the apartment. Kyle was always much better about getting Guy to clean up, but every time Eel asked him to, Guy bitched and complained about Eel's nagging. More fighting always ensued.
With another argument sparked between the two, there was a visitor outside the apartment. He visited from time to time, watching with a displeased frown as his lovers bickered and fought and exchanged blows. Kyle had hoped that this forced time away from him would have made the two realize what was going on and correct it, but it only seemed to be making things worse between them. He leaned his hand on his palm as he watched Eel force Guy into a chokehold, but it wasn't long until Guy thrashed Eel off of himself and caged him up. The more Eel struggled, the tighter it got, and eventually that led to the end of the fight.
Kyle could only sigh, kicking a stone off the roof before zipping back to where he'd been staying. Flying peacefully through the night was somewhat relieving. He'd been avoiding all of his work requirements with the Justice League and instead focused on doing things for the Lantern Corps to keep himself busy. He made sure to stick close, though, as he wanted to be able to return to Earth frequently both to stay where he was calling home, and to occasionally spy on Eel and Guy when he could.
Now he was beginning to second guess his previous decision about whether or not all of this was worth it. His current hope was that Eel and Guy would come to a realization eventually, but nothing good seemed to be happening. All they were doing was fighting, and Kyle just couldn't get it. Why couldn't they get along? What was wrong with sharing ? Kyle loved them both. He was willing to do whatever it took for both of them.
A particularly bad fight occurred about a month into Kyle's disappearance. Tensions were at an all time high between the two, as the fights had turned from blaming each other for annoyances to instead blaming each other for Kyle leaving. The insults stung.
"You can't ever take anything serious. Everythin' is a complete joke to you!"
"And you're always angry, yelling at Kyle and at me! I wouldn't be surprised if you started hitting either of us. You've already proven you'd beat me up."
"I'd never do that to Kyle. You , on the other hand? All you're good for is taking a hit. You're useless to the team, Eel, and you even got sacked by your own buddies way back when you were a criminal. Ain't that funny?"
"Low blow, Guy." Eel doesn't fight him physically again like he wishes he could, but he doesn't have the heart to go all out any more. He was tired. "Fuck you. Fuck. You. " Eel pushed his pointer finger into Guy's chest and pressed in hard with each word. " This is why Kyle left. Because all we do is argue and fight and bitch and moan about and with each other. And I don't even know where to begin to fix it, because I hate you so damn much sometimes."
Guy falls silent, and Eel watches as the tension and anger slowly drains from his face and from his form. Maybe Eel was right. It wasn't either of them that caused Kyle to split, but instead their constant fighting and disagreements about anything and everything. Guy clenched his jaw, setting it before he finally looked up at Eel, who was standing there glumly, arms loose at his sides. When Eel makes no move to speak some more, Guy grumbles his way into saying something.
"... I guess you could be right." Guy muttered it quietly and under his breath, not really wanting to show that he might have to agree with Eel on this one. The more he thought about it, the more it made sense, and the more he was frustrated with himself that he hadn't noticed sooner. Eel perked up a bit, and for once didn't tease him about being right or make some sort of joke. He just… accepted it. "... What do we do to fix this?"
"Well.. I don't know for sure." Eel frowned, not expecting that question right off the bat. However, it's perfectly reasonable to ask and something they should know. He thinks for a few moments as the ideas come to him. "Firstly.. we need to figure ourselves out. We know what we are to Kyle.. but what are we to each other?"
Guy blinked slowly and stupidly as the phrase slowly sunk in, beginning to make sense. "... I would say that we're supposed to at least be tolerant of each other, right..? So.. we do better on not arguin' and fightin.' And say sorry to Kyle. But I'm still kinda pissed he just took off without telling us where he's at. Now we've got to find him. But, uh, first.."
Guy actually looked embarrassed , grasping Eel by the elbow and tugging him close. He flushed, not expecting to be face-to-face with Guy who, after a moment of staring, grasped his chin and pulled him into a rather.. aggressive kiss. Eel was left stunned and with a bitten and swollen lip by the end, eyes literal stars. "Oh, wow. Is that how Kyle feels? Maybe I'm a little jealous .."
"... I don't hate ya, Eel." Guy stepped away, and was that a tinge of pink to his face? Eel opened his mouth, but Guy quickly spoke over him. "Don't get a big head over it. I've got a plan to get Kyle back with us, we just have to find him. I have an idea about where he might be, so listen up…"
Kyle sighed as he trudged his way through the empty halls of the Watchtower. The base was always so quiet and lonely when no one was around. The other members of the League were out, and Eel hadn't been showing up outside of the time he was required to be there. And while Kyle had completely done this to himself, he couldn't help but to feel pretty lonely. He missed Eel's jokes and humor and he missed Guy's boisterous laugh and tight hugs. He missed Eel's massages and Guy's cooking. There was only so much dead space a man could fly through before he got homesick for Earth and his partners.
He's hardly paying attention as he presses the button to open up the door to his room, pulling his mask off of his face and tossing it aside. He turned his back to the room as he flicked the light on, rubbing his face as he turned around to just climb into bed. As soon as he turned around, though- He gasped. "... Shit. You found me."
"We did." Kyle's eyes look over the two sitting in his room, their arms crossed
Guy leaned back in one of the chairs, looking serious and even a little bit scary without even trying. Meanwhile, Eel was sitting in the other chair, using his abilities to look a little more "buff", glasses shaped to match his disapproving frown. Guy stood up with a grunt. "We've been lookin' everywhere for you. Where the hell have you been?"
"None of your business. I'm leaving." Kyle turned back towards the door, making his way to leave before he felt a familiar warmth grasping his forearm. Guy immediately used his own ring to block the door up before standing in front of it, keeping Kyle caged in. The Lantern could easily use his own powers to get out, but… "What are you two planning? You know I don't want to see you. Let me go."
"Ah-ah. Not happening." Eel's grip grows tighter as he drags Kyle's hands behind his back, finally standing up from where he'd been sitting. He dragged Kyle towards him until he fell onto his ass, Kyle's eyes wide as he watched Guy effectively lock the door from anyone getting in or out until Guy decided he wanted to let them all go. "See? You're ours, Kyle. And you made us pretty angry.. annoyed.. all sorts of things. Me and Guy aren't very happy with you."
"What he said." Guy grunted, grasping Kyle by the front of his uniform. He drags him up almost as if it's nothing, throwing him onto the messy bed in Kyle's room. It wasn't nearly big enough for the three of them, but they would make it work. "I'm pissed, Kyle. You really think that me and Eel would be alright with you just ditchin' us and not givin' us a reason? Ignorin' us? Leaving? "
"You two just wouldn't stop fighting with each other…! I didn't want to- hey! Quit that! Guy, Eel!" Guy didn't have to exert much force to start ripping into the bottom of Kyle's uniform, exposing his ass and cock. Eel hummed as he came and sat beside Kyle, using his other hand to slip under the fabric of Kyle's shirt, expanding it until the fabric snapped and the uniform ripped, leaving the chest open and the rest of his uniform in tatters. "You-?! This thing isn't cheap, you know!"
"I know, and we don't give a shit." Guy grunted, manhandling Kyle into his lap just after he'd sat down. Eel didn't seem to mind quite yet that he didn't have much to do, moving to be a bit more in front of the two while Guy had control of Kyle. "I just needed access to everything important. No one here but you gives a shit about your uniform. We're just here to deliver the punishment you deserve."
Eel pressed his fingers into Kyle's mouth as Guy nosed underneath Kyle's ear, teasing the skin there with his hot breaths and his tongue. Kyle gagged around Eel's fingers as he worked to get them slicked up, pressing them down past Kyle's gag reflex so he didn't even have a chance to react. Everything was fine until Guy decided to do a bit more, scraping his teeth along Kyle's neck until he reached his shoulder, making the man shudder.
And then he bit.
Kyle yelled, but he was muffled by Eel's fingers. Guy made sure to bite down hard enough to draw blood, causing more pain to Kyle, who literally shook. Guy reluctantly released his shoulder once satisfied, leaning in to kiss Kyle's cheek, leaving a mark from the blood as if he were wearing lipstick. He grinned, licking his lips. "Alright, Eel. Start stretchin' him. I wanna hear him scream."
As soon as Eel removed his fingers, Kyle's mouth fell open and gasped for breath, trying to calm himself and his body down while Eel moved his hand down between his legs. Guy maneuvered him a bit more, spreading Kyle's thighs with ease. Eel hummed and didn't hesitate to press all three fingers into Kyle, watching as he threw his head back and moaned, ass stretching rather easily to accommodate Eel's fingers even as he expanded them. "Oh? What's this? You're loose… Have you been fucking yourself while you've been apart from us, Kyle?"
"I…" Kyle trembles, not really able to focus with the throbbing pain in his shoulder and Eel's fingers working and stretching him. Guy reached a hand from Kyle's thigh to his cock, squeezing the slowly-hardening member tightly. " Nng..! Fuck, yes, I have, I have - I just missed you two..!"
"Aw, is that so?" Eel couldn't help a grin, glancing from Guy's face to Kyle's. "We missed you too, babe. That's partially why we're doing this. We missed you… but you were also bad. But since you admitted that piece of info so nicely to us, I think you deserve a reward."
Guy began to pump Kyle's cock as Eel leaned forward to kiss him, licking into Kyle's mouth eagerly. Kyle accepts him pretty easily, and as soon as he's able to, Eel does a little trick. He extended his tongue down Kyle's throat, surprising Kyle and making him choke. Eel grinned as he did this, heavily turned on as he felt Kyle shake underneath him and squeeze around his fingers. There was nothing better than getting Kyle to fall apart like this. When Eel felt satisfied with how he'd gotten to fill Kyle's throat, he slid his tongue out, letting Kyle feel it all. His tongue dripped saliva, slipping his fingers free from Kyle's ass as he squirmed, Guy's hand slowing to a stop.
"Did ya like Eel's present, baby?" Guy let Eel hold Kyle up while he worked his hardened cock out of his uniform, pumping it a few times to get himself even more ready. He rubbed the tip of his cock between Kyle's cheeks, catching on his rim and drawing a gasp from Kyle each time. "But don't you want a little more than just a tongue and some fingers? I know you're already ready for me.."
"Yes… yes, Guy, please, give it to me.." Kyle was breathless as he begged, pulling against how Eel held his arms down. He couldn't move any limbs all that much, but he was able to lift himself up enough to grind his ass against Guy's cock, practically using his body to beg Guy to finally use him. It was pathetic how easy it was to break Kyle down into the desperate slut he was, and Guy's ego soared. " Please fuck me, Guy..!"
"Since ya asked so nicely." It wasn't much for Guy to angle his cock a certain way, and then he was sinking to the hilt inside of Kyle. Eel watched with an interested gaze as Kyle's eyes pricked with tears, body shuddering with delight at getting "properly filled." Kyle's poor cock was eager to cum, but he was doing a decent job at holding himself back so far. Eel was sure that now he would finally give in. " Fuck. You feel good, Kyle. Missed this. Missed you. No one's ass is as good as yours. "
" Hah.. I know. You'd never find an ass as good as mine. Fuck, Guy, please move- I want to feel you already." Kyle forces his hips up properly to fuck himself down on Guy's cock, whining quietly each time. Guy did nothing and just let Kyle fuck himself silly, his hands resting on Kyle's hairy thighs and doing minimal work to help. Eel merely played bondage for now, watching Kyle's face and occasionally tweaking the bottom's nipples. He knew he'd have his turn soon enough.
"C'mon, Guy… give it to him. Look at how pathetic his cock is, barely holding himself back from cumming. He's been behaving well, he deserves the reward." Kyle uttered his thanks to Eel as Guy grumbled but listened, wrapping his arms around Kyle's body to hold him in place. He jackhammered into Kyle's body moments later, ripping a cry of surprise from Kyle's throat. Guy grunted as his hands held tight to his body, dragging Kyle down into him with every thrust upwards. It was so loud, and Kyle couldn't help but practically scream with pleasure as he hit that first edge, spilling over and making somewhat of a mess across his own stomach and Eel in front of him.
While Kyle tensed up and moaned. It wasn't nearly as intense an orgasm as he was expecting, twitching but still moaning as Guy didn't slow down one bit. Kyle cried a little more, sniffling, head rolled back against Guy's shoulder as his body lost most of its control for the moment. Eel leaned forward and kissed at his neck, sucking bruises and hickeys into Kyle's skin, his free hand jerking Kyle off rapidly even after he'd just cum. Kyle's thighs jump and twitch as he whines for Eel to stop , already far too sensitive for that.
Guy kept fucking into him, chasing after his own orgasm. Eel could tell how pliant Kyle was going to be for them now, so he let go of his arms, watching as Kyle didn't even bother to do anything with them other than letting them fall to his sides limply. Eel hummed, satisfied, and while Guy kept wrecking Kyle's ass, decided to abandon touching him in favor of getting out of his uniform. His own cock was hard and aching for attention.. but he let Guy fuck Kyle first, awaiting his turn for more.
"Gonna cum in you now, Kyle- that's what you've been waitin' for, yeah? Just wanna get fucked and filled over and over." Kyle nodded as Guy started to stutter in his pace, groaning as he bit into Kyle's neck again. He didn't draw blood this time, but it was enough to spark another orgasm for Kyle as Guy came too, and Eel got to watch as they both shuddered together, Guy squeezing Kyle's waist so hard with his hands that his nails dug in and left marks. "Good boy. Fuck, that's just perfect… Took me so well."
"I think we're treating him too nicely." For once, it's Eel thinking they're being too kind, and usually it was the other way around. Kyle only makes a sort of confused noise as Guy drops him down and leaves him there, cock sitting prettily inside of him. "We're supposed to be punishing him, Guy. Don't you think we should stop giving him what he wants?"
"What do you propose we do, then?" Guy asked, deciding to entertain whatever idea Eel was proposing. Guy had been enjoying fucking Kyle like he was, but he wasn't opposed to something else. "Well.. I can think of one. How about a collar? Kyle deserves to know we own him. Only serves him right that a mutt like him knows his place, yeah?"
"That's a good idea… Do it. Collar and leash. But I've got an even better idea." Eel stepped up to the two, his fingers wrapping around Kyle's cock, stroking the semi-hard length slowly. " This has been treated too kindly. I think we'd better cage him. Can't have him having more fun than us, can we?"
"Eel.. no, no, please don't do that.." Kyle gasped for breath, struggling to get up off of Guy's cock. He gets a few inches up before he's dragged back, grunting. There's a shared look between Guy and Eel before Guy breaks into a grin, using his ring's power to do exactly that. First a collar and leash that Eel didn't hesitate to grab, and then a tight cage around his cock, keeping his orgasms staved off for the near future. " Hng. Please, please take it off, I've been good- "
"Nope. This is what you deserve, Kyle." Eel tugged on the leash so that Kyle chokes and is dragged forward, barely able to catch himself on Eel's thighs. Guy keeps a hold of his waist, recognizing what Eel was wanting to do. "C'mon, Kyle. Let Guy have his fun with your ass while I use your mouth. If you're still being good for us, we'll take the cage off. Doesn't that sound like a good idea?"
"I.. okay .." Kyle swallows the lump in his throat, adjusting how he was sitting on Guy's cock and how he was holding Eel's waist and thighs. Once he was settled in a little more, he dipped his head down enough to take Eel's cock into his mouth, already noticing that Eel was stretching his cock deeper into his throat to make him choke on it. Kyle could do nothing about it but take it, trying to bob his head while not choking on it.
"Good idea, Eel.. He looks so good like this. Filling up all his holes.." Guy grinned, sitting up on his knees a bit more, grasping Kyle's ass and tugging his cheeks apart. He watched his wet cock plunge in and out as he started to fuck Kyle again, hearing his moans be muffled by Eel's cock down his throat. He could so get used to doing this more often. "He can be such a good little slut for us, can't he? Fuck.. " Guy dug his fingers into Kyle's ass, his nails causing little droplets of blood to well up. Eel curled his hands into Kyle's hair, gently tugging him along his length as he bounced with Guy's thrusts. " Hah… Just like that, Kyle. Keep tight just like that."
The two began to fuck Kyle's mouth and ass properly, picking up the pace until it was near brutal for Kyle. He whined and moaned, doing his best to take it without complaint, but the cock cage made it so much less enjoyable. He wanted to cum. He didn't want to sit there and be unable to get off. Yet here he was, taking and taking as Guy and Eel filled his mouth and his ass with hot cum. He struggled to swallow down Eel's cock as he came, but with how long and how far it was bulging his throat, there was no worry there. Guy filled his ass up for the second time, pulling out this time to watch his cum leak out.
"What a slut." Guy grinned, letting Kyle collapse- and when he couldn't hold onto Eel anymore, he fell to the floor in a heap. Eel licked his lips as his eyes roamed Kyle's figure. Kyle managed to get onto his back, clenching his ass in a desperate try to keep the cum still leaking out of his ass. Eel stretched his fingers out and pressed the cum back into him with a frown, and when Guy realized what Eel wanted, he formed a small phallic shape to press into Kyle's ass. "There. Sluts need to be plugged, after all. Look at him.."
"He's making such a mess, though, leaking your precious cum everywhere… I think he needs more punishment." Eel tugged Kyle's leash again, pulling him up until he figured out he needed to sit on his knees. Eel and Guy admired the bruises and blood across Kyle's skin, and the mess his leaking and caged cock had left across his lower stomach. Kyle looked up at them with tears pricking his eyes, his expression pouty and even cuter with his swollen lips. "What do you think, Guy?"
"I think he's beautiful, don't you? But you're also right.." Guy asked, and now that they were taking a short break and standing up, he took the time to strip the rest of his uniform off. "Beautiful boys like him deserve to be shown off, though. Like, just look at him. He's such a good mutt for us. Should take him for a walk… I'm sure everyone's gonna love seeing such a beautiful slut treated as he should be."
"No!" Kyle's eyes went wide, shifting forward- and he crumpled when the plug inside of him jostled against his prostate. "No, Guy, please don't do that. Please. I'm a good slut, your slut, I don't want anyone else to see me like this..! Just you two, just you, please.. "
"Aw.." Eel frowned, tugging the leash tight on Kyle again, watching as tears streamed down his face. "Maybe we shouldn't do that. I don't think I'd want to let everyone else see him like this… he's right. He's ours. This sight is for us."
"Yeah, but can you imagine everyone's faces? Seein' tough Kyle all fucked out and bred by us, on all fours.. our bitch. " Guy grinded his foot against Kyle's caged cock as Kyle tried not to curl in on himself against the pleasure. "That would be so hot… Ugh, but I guess we can save that for another day. Since you begged so nicely for it."
"Thank you, thank you .." Kyle struggled to get the words out, thankful when Guy pulled his foot away. He looked up at them both with teary eyes, body shaking and knees hurting. The hard floor wasn't kind to his legs, but it showcased perfectly where his cock was leaking between the gaps in the cage, leaving a tiny puddle between his legs.
"We'll just fuck him within an inch of his life instead." Guy grinned, taking the leash from Eel. He yanked it hard, causing Kyle to lose his balance and fall forward, hands grasping at the collar. Guy held the line taught and watched him get more and more desperate with his breathing cut off, tears welling up in his eyes as his face turned red. "How about that , huh? You just love when I-!"
" Quit it. " Eel took the leash back and loosened it up for Kyle, watching as he sputtered and coughed, heaving to get his breath back. "Don't fucking do that again, Guy." Eel didn't know if Kyle was into it or not, but at that moment, Eel wasn't. "Not around me."
"It's not about what you like, Eel. Kyle likes to be choked. I've choked him so hard he's passed out before, and he loved it. You know as well as me that he loves his pain." Guy made the cage around Kyle's cock squeeze tighter, watching as Kyle whimpered and shuddered through a dry orgasm, curled up there on the floor. "See? You can't stop me."
"Stop being such an asshole about it! We don't always have to hurt him, whether he enjoys it or not. Can't we just-?"
"Eel.. Guy, please.. I want you two so bad.." The two pause in their fight as Kyle speaks up, pushing himself up to sit on his ass. He pulled the construct out and spread his ass, tongue out and desperate. " Please. Need you both right here in me. Wanna be fucked stupid. Please, Guy, Eel. Give it to me..!"
With a shared look, Eel shrugged, deciding to move past the argument in favor of giving Kyle a real fucking. He removed his glasses without a second thought and the simple action made Kyle absolutely squeal , eagerly clambering up to his knees again, trying to stand up to help them. On the other hand, Guy was staring, dumbfounded.
"You have eyes?! " Comes Guy's surprised gasp, shocked out of the moment. Even Kyle looks at him like he's stupid. " What? I've never seen the guy without those on. I figured it was just, like, a part of him. Like Firestorm or something. Can you blame me?"
"... I guess not. Help me get Kyle up? I wanna take him from behind. You can have his front." Kyle stumbled to his feet as the two hoisted him up. Kyle's nerves were going crazy, still thinking about how he was seeing Eel without his glasses in what felt like forever, his stomach boiling with want and arousal. He knew Eel was going to be insanely serious now, about on the same level as Guy now. It was his idea for the cage, after all.
"Help me get into place, yeah?" Guy asked Eel, pressing the plug further into Kyle for a moment before slipping it free. He held Kyle chest to chest for a bit, brushing his hand across Kyle's tear-streaked cheek. Eel felt a little left out from the soft moment, so he decided to ruin it. He slipped an arm around Kyle's waist and gave a sharp tug to the cage on his cock, practically making him crumble against Guy. The ginger glared at him over Kyle's shoulder before lifting him up. Eel smiled and helped guide Guy's cock into Kyle's entrance again, watching as he slipped in with absolutely no resistance. " Mm. Warm as always, Kyle. Ready for Eel?"
"He is." Eel didn't wait, stepping up to the two. He pressed just the tip in against Kyle's stretched ass, slowly working himself in. He was loose enough to take about half without too much issue, whimpering until Eel shoves his fingers into Kyle's mouth to shut him up. He has to force the last of his cock into him and Kyle has to try his hardest not to bite down on Eel's fingers with the stretch. " There we go. Nice and tight, Kyle. Fuck .."
"Mng.. hah .." Kyle would have said something about how full he was with both Kyle and Guy inside him, but of course Eel had to gag him, keeping him from speaking or saying anything that he wanted to. They've effectively silenced him once again, even as they slowly start a pace of in and out together.
It's faint, but Guy can hear someone heading down the hallway. He hadn't expected anyone to be in the Watchtower at the moment, but his grin widened as he slowed their bouncing of Kyle down. "Eel. Ungag him. I've got an idea. Someone's comin' by the room." Eel's eyes widened when he realized what Guy was referring to, grinning ear to ear as he removed his fingers from Kyle's mouth. He made a confused noise as the two moved him closer to the door, realization dawning. "Let's see how soundproof these rooms really are, yeah?"
In tandem, Eel and Guy started fucking Kyle again, listening to how he tried to hold his moans back but found himself unable to. Eel, since he wasn't actively holding Kyle up, pinched and pulled at Kyle's nipples, drawing out a few more whines and jolts from the poor man. Kyle wheezed for breath between all of his moans, begging them. " Please let me cum, please, take the cage off- I've been good, I have-!"
"I'll let Eel here decide if you've been good enough for that, baby. Be louder." Guy thrusted in harder and Kyle babbled a mess of words and cries, and they all three heard the footsteps pause. Still fucking Kyle within an inch of his life, Guy and Eel met each other's eyes again. "You thinking- you thinking what I'm thinking?"
"Of course. Take the cage off on three." Eel grinned, picking up his pace but abandoning his hold on Kyle's chest. Kyle didn't know exactly where they were going with this, but he knew it couldn't be good for him.
"One.." Eel slipped a hand free from where he was holding Kyle.
"Two.." His hand landed on the button to open the door, pausing for just a moment more.
".. Three!" He pressed the button and the door slid open. Eel pushed Guy backwards until they hit the hallway wall, cutting off whoever it was that was walking down the hallway. As soon as he'd said three, Guy had removed the cage around Kyle's cock and the collar around his neck, allowing him to orgasm freely again. The two hadn't slowed down- in fact, now that there was an onlooker , they seemed to be going harder. "Fuck, Kyle , look-"
The person they'd pulled into their trap was none other than John Constantine, standing there rather dumbfounded. Right place, right time my ass. This is ridiculous. Third threesome I've walked in on this week. Is the universe really trying to tell me to get laid? "Bloody hell.. Why are you..?"
John doesn't really get to say much else, because now that the cage was gone, Kyle was free to cum as many times as he wanted to. Eel took advantage of this, pumping his hand along Kyle's cock eagerly. Kyle's face is blissed out as his body shakes from head to toe, tensing up around the cocks inside him, even more turned on that John was watching them. His toes curled as Guy absolutely nailed his prostate, and that combined with Eel's hand on his sensitive cock sent him tumbling over the edge. The lewd noises of the two slamming into him was quickly drowned out by Kyle's moans, his entire body convulsing as he got to cum.
"... Fuck. Okay, gonna remember that for weeks. I'm out." John rolled his eyes and stepped away, lighting a cigarette as he mumbled under his breath. Guy and Eel still didn't slow down, and in fact they seemed to try to go faster. Kyle was gasping for breath, already feeling like he was going to cum again .
"You did so well, Kyle. Came so pretty for John, didn't ya?" Guy chuckled, letting Eel take more of Kyle's weight as he reached his hand up and around his neck, giving it a squeeze. Kyle's eyes fluttered shut as he seized up in another orgasm, his entrance once again tightening up- which, in turn, caused Eel to groan and spill his own load into Kyle. Guy was cumming not much later, tightening his hold on Kyle's neck and nipping at his shoulder, pleased with how Kyle's upper body was completely limp while his lower half was used and abused.
"God.. that.." Eel was just a little overwhelmed himself, breathing hard and skin sticky from all the work he was putting in. He grunted with exertion as he and Guy managed to waddle back inside the room, dripping fluids onto the floor as they went. Guy shut the door this time, arms shaking. "... now what?"
"Eel.. Your turn to have him for now. I'm pooped. Fill him as you please. You know he still wants more." Guy pulled out of Kyle's ass, letting Eel be the only one to fill him up now. Cum dripped out of him, and Guy's cock was a flaccid mess from cumming so many times within Kyle. " Fuck… Have fun with him, baby."
Guy slapped Kyle's ass, getting the fucked-out man to flinch. His body was battered and bruised, but he didn't beg them to stop- in fact, he'd been looking forward to letting Eel have his way with him. Having them share for most of the night was amazing- and getting fucked by the both of them moments before in front of fucking John Constantine was an experience that Kyle wasn't going to forget any time soon.
Kyle let out a strangled noise as Eel maneuvered him, holding his thighs and spreading him widely in Guy's direction. Eel's body was a little strained having to hold up Kyle's entire weight, but he'd be damned if he let this moment go. He let Kyle lean back against him as he bounced him once, twice on his cock- and then he had an even better idea, taking a moment to reach over to put his glasses back on.
"You're so loose now… Maybe I should do you a favor? I've made myself longer, but.. I can do something else. " Eel grinned as Kyle squirmed, feeling Eel's cock grow and stretch him perfectly. He could feel the tip bulging his stomach and stretching his rim to the point where he believed it might rip. His breathing was labored, digging into his own thighs with his hands. "That's so much better, heh. Now I can feel you up right .."
Finally, Eel began to move, moving Kyle up and down his huge cock. Each movement showed in Kyle's stomach, the distinction moving up and down as the tip speared deep into him. Kyle could barely get words out, tears streaming down his face and saliva dripping from the corners of his mouth. It was a constant assault of pleasure for him, feeling so tight and full. Eel didn't hesitate to start fucking him faster and faster, Kyle's eyes rolling back in his head for the nth time that night.
"Eel… Eel.. " Kyle gasped and moaned, shuddering at a particular press in that hurt , and Kyle's mind melted at the idea of what might be getting messed up inside of him. He also found that it was hot, and his cock spurted a weak amount of cum as he shook through an orgasm at the thought. He was so glad that Guy had long since removed the cage on his cock, allowing him countless orgasms over and over as they pleased.
"You feel so good, Kyle…" Eel licked at the shell of Kyle's ear, tongue dripping and long. He hardly seemed affected other than the deep blush across his face, and Kyle missed seeing his eyes but didn't mind that Eel had put his glasses back on again. It was easier to fade out of his mind this way, focused solely on the engorged cock so deep in his body. "I'm gonna cum and fill you up so good, baby. Gonna get you pregnant. Stuffed with me and Guy's baby."
Kyle barely has time to register that statement before Eel is fucking him as hard as he can, on the path to filling him up with his seed. Kyle tensed and struggled to take it, whining and moaning out. His eyes meet with Guy's, who is sitting on the bed with his legs spread. His hand is pumping his cock in time with Eel's thrusts, face red and expression heated and sultry. He loved seeing Kyle get wrecked.
Suddenly, Kyle feels Eel twitch inside of him, groaning quietly into his ear- and then he feels Eel's hot cum filling his stomach. There's so much more than normal, and Kyle can't tell when it's going to end, whining as Eel keeps thrusting to ride out his orgasm. Kyle feels like a used toy as Eel doesn't stop his pace, chasing after more and more, for another orgasm. His stomach feels so full , even more so than before. His cock was pitifully trying to fill up again for another orgasm, twitching pitifully against his stomach.
"That's a hot sight, Eel. Fill him up some more. Make his stomach swell. " Guy kept jerking himself but this time at a delayed pace, edging himself as he watched his two lovers fuck in front of him. Eel grinned and nodded excitedly, turned on by that thought. He could feel some of the cum leaking out of Kyle's entrance and down his thighs, but Eel didn't let up. Kyle came again, shaking and so out of it- but Eel kept going until he filled him up again.
This time, Kyle knew he was seeing his stomach swell. Only two orgasms of just himself in and Eel had left a small bump of cum in his stomach, barely able to see where his engorged cock was fucking into his stomach anymore. This is insane. There's so much cum. "Eel- Eel, I'm so full , please, it's going to come out of my mouth -!"
"I hope it does. " Eel easily manhandled Kyle to turn over on his back while still impaled on his cock, grasping Kyle tighter as he paused for only a moment to pull Kyle up to him and kiss him. Kyle felt but didn't see how one of Eel's hands stretched to hold the near entirety of his waist, fingers holding the swell of his cum-stuffed stomach. When Eel let him lean back again, he didn't hesitate to fuck another round of cum into him.
"Oh, fuck it.." From where Guy was watching from the bed, he got up, his hard cock hanging heavy between the legs. While Eel was able to stretch and grow his cock as he pleased, Guy's was always so thick and hard. Eel paused in his thrusts as he came up behind Kyle, supporting his back by letting Kyle rest against his chest. Guy held onto Kyle's ass and let Eel hold a little less weight, already guiding his cock towards Kyle's rim. Even though there was already so much cum inside of him, he wanted more. "I wanna breed you some more too, Kyle.. Can't let Eel have all the fun, can I?"
Guy gave Eel a wink over Kyle's shoulder as he pressed his cock alongside Eel's huge length, grunting with the effort. With the both of them in him, it was tight, and Guy didn't know what to think of fucking so much cum in and out of Kyle. It was a tad overwhelming for all three of them as they started their pace, alternating their thrusts to give Kyle a constant assault on his body.
Kyle's mouth hung open as he cried, so many fluids across his body and in him that it was so hard to focus on anything anymore. He'd lost count ages ago of how many times he'd cum, and even now he wasn't sure if Eel and Guy could wring another one out of him. His limbs were jelly except for when one of the two managed to nail his prostate, overwhelming him in the best of ways. He couldn't remember the last time he'd been fucked this thoroughly, if ever.
Kyle was in and out of consciousness, losing track of how many times he felt Guy and Eel cum in him again. He feels like he has a fever, body burning hot and his mind overheating. He manages to cum so pathetically against his stomach and it nearly has him passing out.
Meanwhile, Guy and Eel were having the time of their lives fucking Kyle together. Each time Guy fucked in, Eel was coming out, and vice versa. Their cocks rubbed against each other as they pleased Kyle, leaving another layer of pleasure for the both of them. When it was clear Kyle wasn't going to shut up, though, Guy manifested another construct to plug Kyle's mouth, keeping him muffled.
"Fucking hell, Kyle… Gotta make sure you don't get sick with all this cum in your stomach. And hey, Eel.." Guy licked his lips before he pulled himself and Eel closer, sandwiching Kyle between them and forcing him to hold onto Eel's neck. Like this, Guy could reach Eel's face without Eel even having to use his powers to stretch. He quite liked that, actually. "You're not doin' half bad tonight. I've never seen Kyle so fucked full.. You can consider me impressed. Maybe it is worthless to keep fighting with you."
"Aw, shucks. You really think so?" Eel grinned, his voice a little shaky and worn out from the night. After giving the underside of Kyle's ear another bruising bite, Guy leaned forward and caught Eel's lips in a kiss where he could taste the blood on his tongue. Eel moaned into the kiss, and- he came, filling Kyle up for the nth time of the evening. Guy bit Eel's tongue and kept kissing him, being loud and messy. When Eel pulled away from the kiss to slow down, Guy picked up the pace and kept fucking Kyle. Eel watched Guy's expression melt as he came, filling Kyle up again as his eyes rolled back.
Kyle only whined around the gag once they finished again, panicked and done. Eel and Guy shared a look before they both slowly pulled out. The moment their cum started leaking out of Kyle, Guy moved the construct that was in Kyle's mouth straight to his ass, expanding it until it fit snuggly and didn't let any more of the mess out. The man nearly collapsed when Eel let him down, and he moved to lay him down on the bed instead so he didn't have to use anything. His eyes were glazed over and his body a battered mess. Eel felt a tad bad, and as he returned his body back to normal, he went and found something to clean them all up.
When he came back, Guy was sitting down beside Kyle, running his fingers through his hair. Kyle was still laying where Eel had left him, chest rising and falling with his shaky breaths. "He's out of it. We'll have to talk with him tomorrow." Guy took the offered rag from Eel and wiped himself down of most of the mess while Eel worked on Kyle. Eel cleaned himself up last, and tossed his and Guy's rags somewhere in the room for later. He didn't even want to see how messy the room was yet. He was tired. "Ready for bed?"
"Yeah." Eel let out a pent up breath, slowly sinking to the bed next to Kyle. At this point, wet and nasty spots were unavoidable, so he just worried about snuggling Kyle. Guy laid down on his other side, and once everyone was comfortable, Eel wrapped them all up in a hug. Guy rested his hand on Kyle's bloated stomach, still a little mystified at how it was so full with their cum. "G'night, Guy. I'll see you in the morning."
"... Goodnight, Eel. See ya."
"Mng.." Kyle still felt exhausted, even after passing out for the night. He slowly blinked his eyes open, surrounded by warmth while his body felt absolutely fucked. Barely moving his arm resulted in pain pretty much everywhere, so he tried to stay as still as possible. "Eel..? Guy..? What.."
Sensing Kyle's slight movements, Eel slowly woke up too, groaning as he stretched out. He untangled his arms from around the two of them, gently stroking a finger against Kyle's cheek. "Good morning." Eel cooked a grin, eyes flicking over to Guy as he roused from his sleep, too. "How do you feel?"
"Like shit." Kyle's voice was wrecked, both scratchy and tired. Guy let out a sleepy rumble of a laugh. "That.. was amazing.. but respectfully, what the hell?"
Eel laughed awkwardly, rubbing the back of his neck. "Umm… why don't we get you a bath first? We can all talk about it there. We've got to clean you off.. and get this ," Eel pointed to Kyle's still swollen stomach. "Taken care of. We can't leave it much longer… You could get sick."
"Mm. Personally, I'm gonna miss it, but Eel's right.." Guy frowned, finally sitting up. He helped Eel get Kyle picked up and brought to the bathroom, where they first worked on emptying his stomach out with just a little pain. After the hard part was taken care of, Kyle found himself sitting in the bath with all three of them, his back to Guy's chest and Eel facing him.
"Okay.. do I get to know what I did to deserve all that..? Or the reason why you two get so jealous and angry with each other?" Kyle was sleepy, especially more so when Eel worked on cleaning him, and Guy was massaging his sore body. "And why I literally can't walk?"
"... Sorry." Eel said meekly, gentle as he washed over the healed bites on Kyle's skin. "Um.. I guess the easiest answer is that we got jealous of each other. And it sort of began to reflect in our relationship with you … I was jealous of how easily Guy could talk with you. He always knew what to say to make you feel better, or to laugh, or to get you all sappy and sweet. I wasn't really ever able to do that, and… I started wondering if I was nothing more than just someone good at sex, you know?"
"And funnily enough.. I was jealous because I was worried I couldn't please you as well as Eel does. I mean, the guy is a literal sex God . How was I supposed to compete?" Eel has the gall to look embarrassed while Kyle frowns. "He was also so good at making you smile. It was like… I felt he was better than me."
"But that's not true..!" Kyle broke down into a coughing fit, having Guy rub his back while he recovered. "That's.. not true. You guys are both amazing in your own ways, and.. and I love you both. I can't pick."
"We're not asking you to pick, Kyle." Eel said softly, tossing his glasses aside again, leaning in to kiss Kyle's nose. "We realized we were wrong, which was what led to last night. And, uh… sorry for literally fucking you to where you can't walk. That's going to keep you bedridden for a few days.."
"Is there anything we can do to make it up to ya?" Guy nuzzled Kyle's cheek, and the man flushed. He wasn't expecting the two of them to be so cuddly and cute with him. In a way, it made it all worth it. "We'll do anything."
Kyle paused. His smile grew. "Anything?"
Eel and Guy shared a look.
"Oh my Goddess, look at them. That's hilarious." Diana snickered as she snapped a photo of Guy and Eel. It was quite the sight. "I can't believe Kyle actually convinced them to do this."
Eel and Guy were currently wearing a huge "get along" shirt. They were both inside it, conjoined together as they went about their day. Honestly, they took it like champs the entire week, and Kyle absolutely loved it.